Dr. Gustaf 4 of july one of the greatest holiday known to humanity?


Wednesday, August 9, 2006 - 09:30

thats USA independency day, world have nothing to do with it, Im Brazilian and I just know 4 of july exist because a movie, 4 of july means nothing to me, here in Brazil 7 of september is indenpendency day... and like it I dont know how many countries there are in world... seek out human rights or sumthing like it... not USA holidays... its not an american-only game is it?

just dont make any sense that talk of Dr. Gustaf extending 4 of july to the whole world imho!

Submitted by Tanut on Wed, 2006-08-09 09:37.
Tanut's picture

Well, in some what the independance of America led to the world's first democracy with several other revolutions in europe and elsewhere that scripted similar constitutions...

Plus I'd be willing to bet that 70-80% of Supreme commander will be boughting withing the states, so its more of a marketing thing.

I don't want to knock brazil in any way, but I think for the purposes of the supreme commander storyline, mentioning an aproved request to gain independance without a drop of blood shed (which is very remarkable) wouldn't bring out patriotism in the cybran nation now would it?

I wonder if the Aeon leader might mention somthing about bastile day... After all they were confinded and raiding a prison somehow... hmm nevermind... I thought it made sense...


Submitted by Jun Kazama Mishima on Wed, 2006-08-09 09:49.
Jun Kazama Mishima's picture

well, in someways true, its not about Brazil you know, its just I know this game will long live just like Total Annihilation did, and so it will be around the whole world, that phrase wont make sense to a lot ot ppl, I know it, now if the direct idea of the first democracy bein linked with the American 4th July then bingo, we have sense, the speech is more historical, but the way it is, its too poor, but thats just cause I want SupCom to be the best possible.


Submitted by Grubnessul on Wed, 2006-08-09 12:33.

I don't believe 70-80% of the game will be sold in the usa, I doubt it will even be 50%, you really underestemate the european, south american and japanese market

also the usa wasn't the first democracy, athene was the first. also the netherlands and venice were more or less democratic (democratic for their time ofcourse, Im pretty sure the black or native americans didn't really consider the early usa democratic) long before the usa even exist (venice as sovereign republic lasted for about 1000 years, and the netherlands became a republic after they declared themselve independent from spain in 1582)

but Im getting a bit away from my point, lots and lots of people don't associate 4th of july with freedom. also it's a bit strange that it'll be still remembered x thousands of years in the future, that amount of time allows easily an more worldwide fictional event. in the end I think it's a poor choice to use the 4th of july, for a lot of fans it will be something they only know from their history books or some kind of movie. next time gpg should use a little bit more imagination.

I don't suffer from insanity, I enjoy every minute of it

Submitted by Sedghammer on Wed, 2006-08-09 12:38.
Sedghammer's picture
Tanut wrote:

Well, in some what the independance of America led to the world's first democracy with several other revolutions in europe and elsewhere that scripted similar constitutions...

BAHAHAHAHA! Man, where do you come from? Look in any encyclopedia under democracy and I think you'll find that you are sadly mistaken. That being said....America, f*** yeah!

I think the UEF government could be the reminant of the US government. Or perhaps the world sunk into a dark age and all of history was lost...except for the 4th of July!


Submitted by Nanaki on Wed, 2006-08-09 13:41.
Nanaki's picture

Actually, the successful revolution in America did inspire other revolutionists around the world, although, a lot of them were in Latin America. France's revolutionaries were also inspired by the US's revolution.

While the USA is not the world's first democracy, it is the modern world's first, the governments of the time being exclusively either dictatorships, or feudal monarchies. It was also the first successful revolution against the monarchies, proving that monarchial rule is mortal.


Submitted by Grubnessul on Wed, 2006-08-09 13:49.

funny fact is that the usa revolution was heavily inspired on the dutch rebellion against the spanish

I don't suffer from insanity, I enjoy every minute of it

Submitted by f1dd3 on Wed, 2006-08-09 14:27.
f1dd3's picture

Noooo, you just turned this into an America Vs Europe shouting match. Although the topic was pretty much meant for that. Now this topic will go the same way as the last topic on this subject. But no one blames you, the topic was bound to head in this direction.


Submitted by Grubnessul on Wed, 2006-08-09 14:38.

it's more a usa vs the rest of the world I fear :/

but this topic is hard to discuss without that. most important thing is just to keep it clean

I don't suffer from insanity, I enjoy every minute of it

Submitted by Moriarty on Wed, 2006-08-09 14:43.
Moriarty's picture

Yes. So long as no-one types in ALL CAPS then we're SHOUTING free. Eye-wink


----------------------------------
This post is in the Public Domain.
It doesn't need to be in copywrong limbo for 70+ years and nor do yours!


Submitted by Moriarty on Wed, 2006-08-09 14:41.
Moriarty's picture

You're a little late there Jun. I did lots of compaining about this back in July in the relevent threads. Smiling

Tanut wrote:
Well, in some what the independance of America led to the world's first democracy with several other revolutions in europe and elsewhere that scripted similar constitutions
I hope you're not an American Tanut, because if you are it seems like your history books have been doctored.
The USA is NOT a democracy. It's a Federal Republic. I know this and I'm British (though they don't teach that at school in the UK).
Oh and as already pointed out by Grubnessu, the first Democracy was 2,000 years ago (or so) with the Athenian democracy.

---
You know, now that I think about it (again), why would the Cybrans celebrate a revolution that resulted in a country where lots of people (blacks) were slaves?
If anything shouldn't they be celebrating the resolution of the Civil war which was, amoung other things, over slavery?
After all the non-rebelling Cybrans are quite literally slaves to the UEF when.
So I'll stick to my original conclusion - I'm fine with GPG patting their backs with being American and the 4th of July and all that, but it should have been the UEF celebrating -not the cybran- and it should have been a little toned down.


----------------------------------
This post is in the Public Domain.
It doesn't need to be in copywrong limbo for 70+ years and nor do yours!


Submitted by ElectricTurtle on Wed, 2006-08-09 15:00.
ElectricTurtle's picture

THe UEF are British I tell you! They're a waning colonial empire attempting to consolidate holdings! I'll bet you're a vampire Briton who can't even see himself in the mirror. Eye-winkSticking out tongue

-----------

Quote:
Numquam magnum ingenium sine mixtura dementiae fuit.
There has never been a great spirit without a touch of insanity.
(Seneca Philosophus, De tranquillitate animis)

Submitted by Moriarty on Wed, 2006-08-09 16:08.
Moriarty's picture

As opposed to the USA which is presently trying to create itself a nice empire (Afghan, Iraq etc)? Evil
Eye-wink

Quote:
I'll bet you're a vampire Briton who can't even see himself in the mirror.
That depends. Does that include WANTING to see myself in the mirror? ;-?

----------------------------------
This post is in the Public Domain.
It doesn't need to be in copywrong limbo for 70+ years and nor do yours!


Submitted by ElectricTurtle on Wed, 2006-08-09 14:57.
ElectricTurtle's picture

lol this again?

To state a few key points: the independence of the United States enabled and facilitated (not to mention provided a model) most if not all other colonial achievements of independence. Not only were we the first colony since the Greco-Roman era to say up yours to the mother country and win the ensuing fight, but our independence allowed us to limit the actions of the Europeans to further colonize and control (see The Monroe Doctrine). In this, the US is the first anti-colonial national entity, for which it is never given any credit.

Beyond this, thanks to the existance of an independent US, there is no Nazi Euro-African Empire nor an Empire of Japan astride all of Asia. No other single former colony can reasonably claim to be of such prime importance in the course of history and maintaining freedom in the world at great cost to itself.

In short, the US fought for and won independence first, this precedent enabled all other colonial independence, and it is the most active and most forceful former colonial actor in the attempt to preserve freedom in the world, therefore it is the most important.

-----------

Quote:
Numquam magnum ingenium sine mixtura dementiae fuit.
There has never been a great spirit without a touch of insanity.
(Seneca Philosophus, De tranquillitate animis)

Submitted by Tanut on Wed, 2006-08-09 15:18.
Tanut's picture

First off, yes there were democracies before the USA... What I really meant to say what it is the first modern Democracy.

It is not a pure democracy no... I think the technical term is a representitive democratic/republic state... But I'm not going to bother argueing with that point because I know that I'm too damn lazy to back up my points. So I'll give those both to you.

I would be very suprised if the united states accounted for less than 60% of sales.. I could be very wrong about that so I'll give my tip O' the hat, Wag of the finger there and lets see where the sales end up in three years and have that argument later...

I knew that 90% of what is in the constitution comes right out of french revolutionary liturature... for lack of a better phrase.

Yes I am american. Am I hated already or has the world made thier minds up about us (cough *bush* cough) already? Mabye we will have the respect of the world again when we get a president that has an IQ of more than 91... **** more than 100 at least... *I got the source from searching Google and I saw three "91s". I didn't administer any test.


Submitted by Moriarty on Wed, 2006-08-09 16:29.
Moriarty's picture

Oh dear, ElectricTurtle just put his foot in it. That or I'm about to. Eye-wink

Quote:
Beyond this, thanks to the existance of an independent US, there is no Nazi Euro-African Empire nor an Empire of Japan astride all of Asia.
Excuse me? It strikes me that had Britain maintained control of it's empire, WW1 and WW2 would have been won significantly earlier than they were because the UK would have had that many more resources at it's desposal.
As it was, the USA was late in arriving in BOTH world wars (whether they supported behind the scenes or not is irrelevent) and thus I believe it's feasable to argue that the wars would both have been shorter had Colonial America been in it from the start (and thus proportionally less people would have died).

Quote:
No other single former colony can reasonably claim to be of such prime importance in the course of history and maintaining freedom in the world at great cost to itself.
And the countries it stamps on along the way?
Did I forget to mention near Genocide of the American Indians?
Funny, for a country that touts so many freedoms, historically it's done a very good job of repressing them in others.
Oh and the really, REALLY funny thing is that you're now losing your freedoms to a President/administration who seems to think he's above the Constitution/law. That's why I find it so Ironic that everyone still celebrates 4th of July and yet they do little to nothing about their deminishing freedoms (we're losing ours in the UK too, but at least the gov admit it).

I think that should stir up a hornest nest. Puzzled


----------------------------------
This post is in the Public Domain.
It doesn't need to be in copywrong limbo for 70+ years and nor do yours!


Submitted by Tanut on Wed, 2006-08-09 18:36.
Tanut's picture

It wasn't exactly American culture where we got repressing other peoples from... It is in the nature of human beings... Anybody who has the power to has if it benifited them... China, Japan, Korea, vietnam, Usa, Canada, Mexico, Spain, Brazil, Germany, England, France, heck the whole world is guilty. We study history to attempt to not make the same mistakes that we have in the past... we now know better... they didn't. Why are we being blamed for what unlearned ancestors did?


Submitted by vissroid on Wed, 2006-08-09 18:48.
vissroid's picture

nicely said. you pretty much said what I fealt but at the time I couldnt think of how to say it. Smiling

__..)/..____..)/..__
¯¯””/(”¯¯¯””/(”¯¯¯
Arguing on the internet is like running in the Special Olympics... Even if you win...
You're still retarded...

Prints


Submitted by Moriarty on Thu, 2006-08-10 04:03.
Moriarty's picture

Yes, but most of the world doesn't go around raving about how "Free" they are and then "liberating" other nations. Smiling

----------------------------------
This post is in the Public Domain.
It doesn't need to be in copywrong limbo for 70+ years and nor do yours!


Submitted by ElectricTurtle on Thu, 2006-08-10 09:35.
ElectricTurtle's picture

Alright girlfriend, because you had to go there, we'll talk a little bit about the last six years. You do realize you're jumping on the bash-America train over the events within a span of time which compared to vastness of history amount to little more than a heartbeat. So America isn't allowed to have a bad day eh? Let's forget all about the crimes committed by the British in her colonies, let's forget about Neville Chamberlain because after all only American political figures can be foolish.

Moriarty wrote:
It strikes me that had Britain maintained control of it's empire, WW1 and WW2 would have been won significantly earlier than they were because the UK would have had that many more resources at it's desposal.

The UK mismanages resources compared to Americans. They have had control of Canada just as long as they would have had what is now the US, and Canada is larger and has just as much in natural resources as the US, but Canada is still a podunk nation and was even less valuable in the 40s. (I mean absolutely no disrespect to those brave Canadians who fought hard and well in the wars. I say only that objectively the productive capacity of Canada was underutilized as a direct result of British mismanagement compared to the US.)

Quote:
As it was, the USA was late in arriving in BOTH world wars

Late? Those were European conflicts. We had no obligation at all, the only reason we showed up in WWI is the Germans wouldn't leave our ships alone, and we felt sorry for you. If it weren't for the fact that Germans were allies of the Japanese when the latter attacked us, you might never have seen any US involvement in WWII. Regarding that involvement, the US was ALWAYS on point. During the Normandy invasion the US was assigned more difficult landing zones than the British and Candians. During the Allied bombing campaign the US did all the higher casualty rate daylight bombing while the British were given the lower casualty rate night bombing. US troops were frequently put between the enemy and the British as in the original design for the invasion of Sicily (at least until Patton said up yours to SHAEF and left the British to handle themselves while he took the rest of the island).

Quote:
And the countries it stamps on along the way?
Did I forget to mention near Genocide of the American Indians?

Who cries for the Helots? The simple fact of the matter is that the US did not treat the Indians any worse than the Spartans treated the Helots, or more relevantly the Spanish treated the aboriginal people south o' the border, or the French treated Africans, or the Dutch treated Polynesians, or on and on. It's a European mindset, and America is country created by Europeans. So you can stop pointing fingers because you're no better.

Quote:
Funny, for a country that touts so many freedoms, historically it's done a very good job of repressing them in others.

I'm assuming that you're referring to martial law, which has been used at times in recently occupied nations under US control. I suppose that's a LOT WORSE than, you know, people being dismembered and raped and killed. Man, the US is really bad, maybe sometimes keeping people without trial. That's a lot worse than state-mandated dismemberment, rape, and death. Boooo US.

Quote:
Oh and the really, REALLY funny thing is that you're now losing your freedoms to a President/administration who seems to think he's above the Constitution/law.

Yeah, we are. He's a mediocre to bad President/leader. You've never had bad leaders? Uh-huh. STFU.

Quote:
That's why I find it so Ironic that everyone still celebrates 4th of July and yet they do little to nothing about their deminishing freedoms (we're losing ours in the UK too, but at least the gov admit it).

Yup, we still celebrate it because it's not about current events, it's about an ideal. That ideal is still alive, and there's still hope through the legislative process to fix things.


Submitted by MadBoris on Wed, 2006-08-09 19:19.
MadBoris's picture

Babble all you want, thinking you sound so intelligent, putting down the USA.

We celebrate our independence day here, we aren't aplogizing for it. Don't like it? Too bad!

Stop with the anti-usa crap, it's dripping from your ears.

Take your politics ELSEWHERE!

~~
"The world moves, and ideas that were once good are not always good. In preparing for battle I have always found that plans are useless, but planning is indispensable." - Dwight D. Eisenhower


Submitted by Nanaki on Wed, 2006-08-09 19:44.
Nanaki's picture

This thread has gone beyond the boundaries... should have been locked hours ago.


Submitted by vissroid on Wed, 2006-08-09 19:54.
vissroid's picture

Jeez boris I think you may have givin me another reason to join SupComHQ(if your infact the same madboris that does the news there). lol
the reason I never joined supcom universe was becuase they were always talkin like that there(it always pissed me off) and I figured the same there too.
do you not tollorate that there? cuz if not then oOo. you might have a new member. Laughing out loud

if I did just babble to you for no good reason then dont mind me. Im crazy. lmao

__..)/..____..)/..__
¯¯””/(”¯¯¯””/(”¯¯¯
Arguing on the internet is like running in the Special Olympics... Even if you win...
You're still retarded...

Prints


Submitted by MadBoris on Wed, 2006-08-09 20:11.
MadBoris's picture

All I know is enough is enough, people got their shots in, lets move on.

It seems like ET got his wish, things are looser around these parts, but it does start to mimic a bar down some dark alley with toothless grandmas looking to date drunken blatherers. And it's hard to tell which is which. Eye-wink

*Reminisces the old days when GPG grenades would have been lobbed in.* Sad

~~
"The world moves, and ideas that were once good are not always good. In preparing for battle I have always found that plans are useless, but planning is indispensable." - Dwight D. Eisenhower


Submitted by vissroid on Thu, 2006-08-10 02:06.
vissroid's picture

yeah it has kinda calmed down a bit. Im wondering if the threads are needing more help(like night watch...lmao)
but I wanted to ask you a question. are you guys at HQ goin to have groups(kinda the way planet annihilation and TAuniverse goes?
Just tryin to find a place that does units like that(and not to mention tryin to find a group to do a TA race mod of gettin Arm and Core into the game and up to scale) Evil

__..)/..____..)/..__
¯¯””/(”¯¯¯””/(”¯¯¯
Arguing on the internet is like running in the Special Olympics... Even if you win...
You're still retarded...

Prints


Submitted by Moriarty on Thu, 2006-08-10 04:20.
Moriarty's picture

I like to call it "informed discussion".
I can provide links if you like:
-Bush Guantanamo Torture
-American Citizens held indefinately by the US?
-NSA wiretapping US citizens without a warrant
I think that will do for starters. America Bashing? It's not meant to be. I call them facts.
I can just as easily find Britain bashing stuff, but we aren't breaking our own laws to do these things (unfortunately or we could try to stop them).
Oh, and I've spent 6 months living in the USA to date, so I have some idea about the place. Eye-wink


----------------------------------
This post is in the Public Domain.
It doesn't need to be in copywrong limbo for 70+ years and nor do yours!


Submitted by SuperiorX on Thu, 2006-08-10 01:28.
SuperiorX's picture

no comment No Comments PLEASE FOR GODS SAKE NO COMMENTS Sticking out tongue

SuperiorX


Submitted by Bagheera on Thu, 2006-08-10 09:45.
Bagheera's picture

Why the hell has this ugly topic re-emerged? Ok, I'll just add my 2 cents, trying to be as unbiased as possible, and then leave it at that.

You see, whether you Americans realise it or not, your generally seen by the rest of the world as a big-headed, cocky, self important lot. And you see, no one likes a big headed, cocky, self important person, group, or even nation. This image is brought on by Americans like ET, voicing their patriotic/obnoxious opinions (choose what you will). No doubt this will enflame some people here, but that is the case, like it or not.

And thats it in a nutshell. Its nothing malicious, and its not anything extreme, but even as a pro-American I find it hard to tolerate this "aura" America gives off. That being said, I appreciate alot of Americans are good hospitable people, and its a shame the actions and words of the few reflect badly on the whole.

I say the above with no bitterness or sting intended. I just hope by writing this some Americans will at least understand why there is alot of anti-American sentiment, and at most will re-evaluate their opinions on America in the world at large.

Thats my 2 cents anyway, and thats about all I have to say on the matter.
_____________________________________________

Whoever said anything is possible obviously never tried slamming a revolving door...


Submitted by DragonTeeth12 on Thu, 2006-08-10 10:23.
DragonTeeth12's picture

Folks have had their say (many twice, since this is a duplicate of another almost identical thread), but no one other than the OP has bothered to bring SupCom into the discussion.

I doubt there's a day that could be chosen for the event without someone taking umbrage - even as to using the type of calendar.

What's interesting is that I believe all this talk stems from the July 4th "post" from Dr. Gustaf on http://www.supremecommander.com.
Specificially located here, the memo is dated July 4th and says "This week we celebrate Independance Day, one of the greatest holidays known to humanity."

Interesting that it is automatically assumed by some that "Independance Day" for Dr. Gustaf is July 4th (note the word "week" in his sentence....as in 7 days, any of which could have been Independance Day). July 4th is the day the letter was published (both in the future and on the site, I believe). No one's ever said - except here by posters making their own assumption - that July 4th was the Independance day referred to. Hard to believe in the time between Now and Then that there's no possibilites for any similar event in July. July _was_ Cybran month, you may recall.

True, the post makes reference to colonial Americans, just as early US presidents made reference to French and Spanish armies in speeches, and later to British and French, Dutch, Greek, Phillipino and other freedom fighters circa WWII. I'm sure rulers in other countries do the same. It's a comment referring to the grasping for liberty (in this case, from their perception of UEF dominion).

Since nothing outside of the OP even mentions SupCom, this obviously has nothing to do with SupCom. And since the premise is about something that isn't true, it's a futile discussion.

So, history repeats itself as I close this thread.
Feel free to continue the non-SupCom/non-GPG part of the discussion on another website, though Smiling

DragonTeeth12
GPG moderator


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.